Crucial Lens Essay on Othello
Adrienne Rich once said, “Lying is made with words but likewise with silence”. This indicates that lying isn’t only when one informs something false, however also when one does not speak at all, the fact consisted of. This is usually real. A text that highlights this quote would have characters who do not reveal the reality at a time when doing so would be important. Othello by William Shakespeare pleases this quote with characters like Emilia and Iago. Characters lie to cover something, but when one does not state anything to inform the truth, it still counts as lying.
Emilia discovers the handkerchief that the protagonist, Othello had actually given to his other half, Desdemona, but instead of providing it back; she offers it to her partner Iago. Othello has been convinced by Iago that Desdemona is cheating on him with Cassio. When Desdemona looses the handkerchief she asks Emilia, “Where should I lose that scarf, Emilia?” she merely replies, “I know not, madam” (III. iv. 23-24). Despite the fact that she offers it to Iago, she does not say so. Othello is even more persuaded that Desdemona is cheating on him and chews out her. Emilia just stands in the room saying absolutely nothing.
This silence costed the faith in Othello to diminish and therefore is as bad as the important things that her other half does. Although Iago was the true liar in the play, Othello’s failure to challenge Desdemona of his suspicions contributed to his failure. As Iago fed a growing number of nonsense to Othello, the more he had thought that she was unfaithful. After Iago leaves, Othello mutters to himself, “If she be false, paradise mocks itself! I’ll not think’t.” However when Desdemona asks, “How now, my dear Othello?” he could not confront her, only stating, “I have a discomfort upon my forehead, here” (III. ii. 320-326). He could have quickly just asked her where the scarf was, or as quickly dealt with Cassio or Desdemona to inform them what was on his mind. Rather, he keeps quiet and just assumes whatever Iago states holds true. By keeping to himself, Othello is actually lying to himself. The author uses remarkable paradox to reveal the reader info Iago and we understand, but Othello and the other character do not. In truth, all the other characters involved know a piece of the information, and all it takes is for them to come together, and the puzzle might have been fixed.
Not one point in the play do they do that, till the end, which contributes significantly to the catastrophe of Othello. By not informing the fact, the characters in Othello all added to the death of Desdemona. An innocent lady so in love, who would not have traded the world to be unfaithful, was accused and eliminated by her envious partner. All of which might have been prevented if any among the character would have spoken the fact and not keep to themselves information they possessed. Iago was not the only phony in the play, they all were, for silence is genuinely a lie.