Life Dependence and Miss Brill
The human brain can be the most unsafe tool in the human race. The brain can be a beneficial and productive tool when utilized in properly, such as constructing the understanding of a private to utilize in a specified field to add to society. On the flip side, the brain can be a damaging tool to anyone who suffers a mental problem, due to the fact that the brain continues to think of the negative elements in life and continues to harp on them till the person is so deep within his/her own mind that one can not escape. David Hellerstein states, “Take anxiety as an example: typical symptoms consist of mood modifications (undoubtedly) but also trouble with cognitive functioning-trouble remembering things, trouble making decisions, preparation, setting concerns, and acting.” When somebody is battling against themselves, there is no place to pull away to, triggering an individual to develop an alternative truth that he/she will pull away to within his/her own mind to conceal from such a problem. When it comes to Katherine Mansfield’s “Miss Brill,” Miss Brill is wrong for looking for haven from her loneliness in her self-created, imaginary life since it is not healthy.
Miss Brill is incorrect due to the fact that her fictional life is constructed entirely around her anxiety. Campos et al. state, “Individuals with reliant depression are preoccupied with social concerns such as sensations of isolation, disregard, and desertion” (17 ). Miss Brill portrays to have most, if not all, of the social problems discussed by Campos et al. In the story, through Miss Brill’s viewpoint, the reader sees a lonely female who enjoys her ritual Sunday outing to the park. Every Sunday, Miss Brill goes to the park to escape what Mansfield calls the “little dark room” in which Miss Brill remains (150 ). She gets so much pleasure from the basic acts of listening and passively embedding herself in the company of others. Miss Brill innately incorporates herself with other people to ease the depression triggered by the isolation that she has built up throughout the week of being by herself. Her main function in participating in the weekly ritual is to meet her need to be a part of something. Miss Brill is looking for a sense of neighborhood or a sense of function and/or addition with the complete strangers that she sees and listens to in the park. She hopes that, as Mansfield discusses, “no doubt someone would have discovered if she had not existed” (149 ). However, Miss Brill’s issues of anxiety in life can not be satisfied by living a passive life. The act of living a life through the fantasy of her creativity is exclusively reliant on her presence in the park, sitting where what Mansfield calls Miss Brill’s “special seat” (148 ). Miss Brill had unwittingly produced a cycle that she can not get away from-a cycle that was developed from depression, triggering her to develop the alternate reality, giving her the pleasure principle that she desired, which will at some point collapse.
Miss Brill wrongfully develops her imaginary life since it continues to offer low self-confidence. Numerous events lead up to Miss Brill’s self-created life being taken apart. One example takes place while Miss Brill is seeing the crowd in the park. She associates herself with a various senior woman in a fur hat who experiences a gentleman. The female is delighted with the opportunity of companionship. The male rudely disregards the woman’s enjoyment to connect, lights a cigarette, and snaps the match as he leaves. Miss Brill relates to the female, feeling a sense of humiliation and low self-esteem that associates to her own life. The discomfort strikes so deep she feels that the band playing in the background starts to play more softly. Banchs states, “What we keep as specific memory are not our individual inexact questing experiences however rather the cumulative representations of that past which are mobilized from present needs” (31 ). More description discusses that Miss Brill recalls previous memory to help herself handle her existing problems, whether the memory is real or not is another problem. Miss Brill’s pain from low self-confidence activates a need for a previous memory, sending her retreating into her “starlet” persona, as Mansfield’s describes, to prevent the vulnerability of being hurt (150 ). Miss Brill’s actress persona creates a wall to secure her from experiencing the exact same hurt as the female in the fur hat, offering Miss Brill the security to carry on enjoying and listening. Miss Brill suffers from low self-confidence when she is confronted with the drastic reality of being lonely when a young couple takes pause at her “unique seat.” The boy says “that foolish old thing” when describing Miss Brill (Mansfield 150). Knowing Miss Brill is listening, the young man continues by saying, “Why does she come here at all-who desires her? Why doesn’t she keep her silly old mug in your home?” (Mansfield 150). Once once again caught off guard, Miss Brill instantly feels the defensive wall that she has actually so carefully produced start to tumble internally. The breakdown of Miss Brill’s defensive wall forces her to face the reality that she is undoubtedly not a crucial member of the crowd or neighborhood that surrounds her, triggering her own built persona to fall upon deaf ears.
More thinking to why Miss Brill is wrong for continuing to pull back to her self-constructed fictional life is that in doing so nothing gets solved, causing her more pain. Cambron and Acitelli state, “Findings suggest that individuals whose self-esteem is determined by their friendship quality participate in maladaptive interpersonal behaviors that eventually cause experiencing higher depressive signs” (701 ). Clarifying that if Miss Brill stays based on her quality of friendships, she will only intensify her anxiety. Miss Brill’s depression issue becomes genuine when she leaves her “unique seat” and go back to the life of vacuum that remains. The brief trip to the park is not a long-term repair to the problem of loneliness that Miss Brill suffers. Isolation can not be fixed due to the fact that it is only an item of her own income. Continuously vulnerable to being injured, Miss Brill sets herself up to be faced by her own unwanted truth. To repair her problem, she must leave behind her fake life and devote herself to building genuine personal relationships with others.
Miss Brill is wrong in using a self-created, imaginary life to fix her issues of isolation and anxiety since her problem feeds off anxiety and low self-esteem while staying unsettled. As Zittoun and Cerchia state,” [I] magination can be viewed as triggered by some interfering with occasion, which creates a disjunction from the individual’s unfolding experience of the ‘”genuine”‘ world, and as unfolding as a loop, which ultimately comes back to the actual experience” (305 ). Clarifying that Miss Brill will constantly be forced to face her real issue of solitude. After being emotionally beaten and broken, Miss Brill runs away the park to return house, the home she views as more of a cupboard. Having her sense of self-respect marked down a lot, she does not feel commendable sufficient to indulge herself with the conventional slice of honey cake purchased from the baker’s on her way house. Although Miss Brill attempts to dodge reality functions as a coping technique to fill deep space of her solitude, the systematic tactic is not foolproof. Miss Brill is able to trick herself for only a limited quantity of time, making the reality that much more difficult to deal with once she returns to her location in the cupboard-like space in which she resides in.