The well-known play, “Romeo and Juliet” by William Shakespeare, have actually been adapted into 2 movies. Zeffirelli directed a historical portrayal of the movie, and Luhrmann directed a contemporary analysis of the film. Both variations were depicted in Shakespeare’s original text.
Each movie had usage a different approach when it pertained to setting, props and mood. In Zeffirelli’s variation, the setting was an entertainment of the 14th century, in the city of Verona, Italy along with ambience of classical music, traditional dancing, renaissance clothes and Shakespearean discussion.
Luhrman’s Hollywood remake called “Romeo+Juliet” had a mix of initial Shakespearean dialogue with a modern twist. The atmosphere remained in Verona beach in the 1990’s that included vehicle chases, costume celebrations and gunfights. The twist of this variation was to imagine the awful storyline in a modern perspective and how it would fit into today’s society. The props in both motion pictures were different. For example in the Luhrman’s variation, money was used rather of gold coins. This is revealed when Romeo pays the apothecary for toxin.
In this version weapons replaced swords. This is shown in the fighting scenes of the motion picture. Zeffirelli’s had kept the gold coins. An example can be when Romeo offers these coins. He had actually likewise kept the swords for the fighting scenes also, so it can be relevant and historically accurate to Shakespeare’s time. The moods in each motion picture were really different. In Zeffeirelli’s version the movie was really intense and the audience might feel the love, sorrow, rage, and enmity of each character. An example can be when Mercutio is offering the well-known Queen Mab speech.
In this scene the audience can see that Mercutio not simply a joker however he likewise has a dark side. On the other hand in Luhrmann’s version the state of mind was very comedic and less suspenseful. This was shown from the more funny yet enthusiastic stars. An example can at the celebration when Luhrmann dresses Paris in a spaceman fit to make him look ludicrous and utilizes him as comic relief. This signifies that Paris is not what Juliet wants in a male and understands that Romeo is her real love. The death of time in Zeffeirelli’s variation was slower than the faster paced modern variation.
In both films, a couple of scenes were neglected, such as the fight with Paris at the Capulet’s burial place. In conclusion, Luhrmann and Zeffirelli both analyzed Shakespeare’s play, “Romeo and Juliet”, effectively. One was presented with a modern-day twist and the other provided in the real times of the original play. Personally, I enjoyed watching Zeffirelli’s version more because it portrayed the genuine work of Shakespeare and the past of Verona, Italy. There was also more suspense and one could feel the stress and emotions of the characters more.