The Crucible. Significant Irony
Passage-based essay 2. The moment in which Elizabeth informs a lie in order to save her spouse’s life, indicates dramatic paradox. The playwright makes this take place when very first John Proctor calls Abigail’s a slut and, in spite of the humiliation he felt, exposed his affair with her. As Danforth can not think the seventeen year-old lady is really a “whore”, he asks Goody Proctor to come approximately check the truth of this charge. Prior to she goes into the court, John swears Elizabeth is an extremely truthful woman so when she rejects his infidelity to conserve him, there is a contrast as she is supposed to be trustful.
They both risk their reputation with the intent of conserving each other’s life in different methods: John confessing his sin and Elizabeth lying. The drama and the paradox are clearly shown by Miller in 2 pertinent elements. In the first place, Proctor makes one desperate attempt for this authority by conquering his desire to safeguard his good name, exposing his own secret sin. Although he realizes that admitting his lechery with Abigail will bring pity and awful consequences upon himself and his household, he selects to save the reputation and life of his spouse and compromising both his honor and his integrity.
As he puts it, “(…) A guy will not cast away his reputation. You undoubtedly know that.” In order to Danforth to believe him and not Abigail who was denying it, Proctor exposes himself in the court. He intends to replace his wife’s suspected guilt with his own regret and bring down the dismissed servant in the process. In the second place, before the upset court officials call for Elizabeth Proctor to learn the fact about John and Abigail and to verify his faithlessness, Proctor states: “In her life, sir, she have actually never lied.
There are them that can not sing, and them that can not weep- my spouse can not lie. I have paid much to discover it (…).” Elizabeth, who has lived by the truth as his spouse holds, when questioned about Proctor’s fidelity, her soul was twisted: if she reported the truth, she might ruin her spouse’s credibility, however if she lies, it implies breaking the pledge to God. As she is noble, Elizabeth chose to lie and conserve Proctor. What Elizabeth was not familiar with is that his husband ad already admitted, and when she got to know it, she had a mix of emotions: on one hand, she felt awful because she lied for absolutely nothing and condemned herself to hell for such a sin and John as well; however on the other hand she understood that Proctor’s name was very important to him, and that he would not ruin his credibility by admitting an affair unless he really loved her, so she could lastly trust him again. The only one fortunate was Abigail Williams, who continued to lying: the court, which ought to be an instrument of truth, is in the position of condemning those who tell the fact and believing phonies.