To what extent can Tybalt truely be blamed for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet.Tybalt is shown
as a villain in Romeo and Juliet but how much can he truly be blamed? Tybalt is a proud and patriotic Capulet cousin, his name reflects his character (tybalt implies the prince of cats) he is a rare swordsman and fights with honor, although he does take individual insults really far he can be seen in 2 methods, first as a racist, prejudiced against the Montagues or 2nd as an honorable guy who fights for household and what he thinks to be right, Mercoutio describes him as More than prince of felines, I can inform you. O, he is the bold captain of compliments. He battles as you sing prick-song, keeps time, range, and percentage; rests me his minim rest, one, two, and the 3rd in your bosom: the really butcher of a silk button, a duellist, a duellist; a gentleman of the extremely first home, of the first and 2nd cause,” (2. 4. 26) In scene 1 act 1 Rioting has actually broken out in between the 2 households, Tybalt must be delegated denying a deal of peace from the Montagues, What, drawn, and talk of peace! I hate the word, As I dislike hell, all Montagues, and thee: Have at thee, coward!” (1. 1. 72) However following the riot Tybalt and indeed all Capulets and Montagues are released a caution that if violence is broken out once again somebody will pay the cost “If ever you disrupt our streets once again, Your lives will pay the surrender of the peace.” (1. 1. 97) In this Tybalt does receive a caution so although he can be blamed for worsening a fight in act 1 scene 1 he can not be further penalized.
Some would think that Tybalt does not truly listen to the Princes warning which reveals a lack of respect for authority which is all part of the reason that the Capulets and the Montagues are battling anyhow given that, in Act 3 scene 1 Tybalt returns to combat Romeo but in reality Tybalt is not trying to disturb the peace, he is merely attempting to win his own back on Romeo. When Romeo, Mercoutio, Benvolio and several other Montagues Gatecrash the Capulet celebration they are simply doing it out of fun but to Tybalt it is an act of dishonor, he even attempts to attack Romeo throughout the party, This, by his voice, should be a Montague. Bring me my rapier, young boy. What dares the servant Come hither, cover ‘d with an antic face, To fleer and scorn at our solemnity? Now, by the stock and honor of my kin, To strike him dead, I hold it not a sin.” (1. 5. 59) however is avoided by Capulet who is feeling generous, when Tybalt challenges him Capulet knows that the worst charge he can dispense is to hurt his honor so he deals with Tybalt Like a naughty kid, “He will be sustained: What, goodman kid! I say, he shall: go to; Am I the master here, or you? go to. You’ll not endure him!
God will heal my soul! You’ll make a mutiny among my guests! You will set cock-a-hoop! you’ll be the guy!” (1. 5. 81) This leads Tybalt to blame his penalty on Romeo and decides to eliminate him to likewise restore his honor When Romeo does not respond to the letter that Tybalt sends to Romeo issuing him an obstacle Tybalt sees this as much more of a dishonor and now rages, The fight that occurred between Mercutio and Tybalt can not be entirely blamed on Mercutio. Tybalt should take on a few of the blame, as he was the one that challenged them, making rude comments about Romeo thou art a villain.” (3. 1. 61) “Therefore turn and draw.” (3. 1. 67) The second quote is when Tybalt obstacles Romeo to a sword battle, this is when Mercutio actions in and Tybalt is more than pleased to combat and beat him. To make matters worse, Tybalt returns to where he has simply killed Mercutio, after he realises that nobody understands what has occurred (except for the people that were there) and challenges Romeo again. This time Romeo, acting on behalf of his dead friend attempts to get revenge by agreeing to combat with Tybalt.
This is where Romeo ends up being the one to blame. If Romeo had actually accepted that his buddy was dead then he would not have killed Tybalt and rather gone to grieve over Mercutio. This would have indicated that Tybalt would have been punished rather of Romeo. In conclusion I believe that Tybalt remains in truth simply a male raised with the idea that Montagues are inferior and Capulets superior, although he has a prejudice versus the Montagues I do not believe that he is to blame for what took place because he does not deliberately attempt to trigger suffering.